The tape described in the Thalia Graves suit differs in several key ways from the one sought by Ariel Mitchell-Kidd, meaning there could potentially be a host of explicit Diddy tapes circulating in the mogul’s social circle.

For starters, Graves’ alleged incident occurred in Diddy’s Bad Boy Records office in New York, and wasn’t part of a freak-off event. Though Diddy and his legal team have vehemently denied the charges levied against him, the rapper has made no secret of these freak-off events, and has even spoken about them publicly.